Students organizing
MP3 players in ProductWorld

EVALUATION

To determine the value of ProductWorld as a design support tool it was evaluated within the setting of a design course. In this course a group of Industrial Design Engineering students, who were working on the design of a portable MP3 player, used the ProductWorld prototype to index and explore a collection of existing MP3 players. Their experiences clearly indicated the potential value of the tool. Organizing products through its interface, which was done with enthusiasm and dedication, was considered to be insightful and valuable to their own design process, while the exploration of these organizations was perceived as engaging and stimulating. Although the results of querying the organized collection were found to be difficult to interpret, they did provide the students with a better understanding of the relationships between the products, as well as between the used similarity criteria. The specific design character of the program, with its emphasis on interactivity, aesthetics and usability, was highly appreciated, contributing to its acceptance as a design tool.

 



Examples of organizations made in ProductWorld

"Designing
with
precedents" wallpaper
(1024X768, 52 Kb)


GENERAL DISCUSSION pdf (420 Kb)

Possible applications and implications of the research in this thesis are discussed for four areas of interest: design education, design practice, design methodology and design support systems. It is suggested that the typological approach and its implementation in a tool like ProductWorld might help students to overcome their reluctance towards studying existing products and integrating elements from them into their own designs. It is further advocated that research in design has to concentrate more of its attention to the development of the physical product, and that the ideas brought forward in this thesis could provide directions for this. Finally, building high quality prototypes that are based on a thorough understanding of the context of design is promoted as a valuable design-driven research approach.

REFERENCES + APPENDICES pdf (1.5 Mb)

"Designing
with
presidents"
at Amazon.com ;-)
(Thanks to
Daniel Saakes)